I'm thinking of getting a Subaru Forrester. Any other cars or small SUV's I should look at?

I commute from Buffalo to Rochester for work 3 days a week, so I'd like something thats all-wheel-drive with decent gas milage. I need it to be dependable even after it racks up a lot of milage and has to be an automatic. I don't really want to spend more than 25K, and I'm looking at either new or under 15000 miles.